SkinbaseNova/docs/nova-cards-v3-audit-checklist.md

# Nova Cards v3 Audit Checklist

Audit date: 2026-03-28

Source of truth reviewed:
- `.vscode/agents/skinbase-nova-cards-system_v3.md`
- Nova Cards controllers, services, models, routes, React Studio UI, migrations, and feature tests

Validation status:
- Verified with `php artisan test tests/Feature/NovaCards`
- Result: 72 passing tests, 489 assertions

Follow-up roadmap:
- `docs/nova-cards-v3-priority-roadmap.md`

Status legend:
- `[x]` Implemented end to end or clearly present
- `[-]` Partially implemented or scaffolded
- `[ ]` No clear implementation found during audit

Important note:
- The v3 agent file is a roadmap/spec, not a strict shipping checklist. Several sections describe target-state product direction rather than features that are already expected to exist in full.

## 1. v3 schema versioning and normalization

- [x] `schema_version` is stored and normalized for v3 cards
- [x] New projects normalize to v3 shape
- [x] Legacy v1/v2 projects are detected and upgraded
- [x] Save flow rewrites cards into the newer project structure
- [x] Compatibility behavior is covered by feature tests
- [-] Explicit admin rerender/backfill tooling for migrated cards was not found

Notes:
- Implemented via migration, `NovaCardProjectNormalizer`, and v3 tests.

## 2. Advanced editor architecture improvements

- [x] Structured project JSON exists with major v3 sections like `canvas`, `background`, `text_blocks`, `frame`, `effects`, `export_preferences`, and `source_context`
- [x] Multiple text blocks are supported
- [x] Additional body and caption blocks can be added and edited
- [x] Layout presets, alignment, position, padding, max width, typography, frame, effects, background modes, overlays, focal position, and packs are exposed in the Studio UI
- [x] Background upload works through the draft API
- [x] Mobile step-based flow exists for Studio
- [x] Version history and version restore exist
- [x] Block reordering UI now exists for text blocks
- [x] Compare versions UI now exists at a useful summary level
- [x] Dedicated quick mode versus advanced mode switch now exists
- [-] The editor is structured and block-based, but not a full layer tool
- [-] Visibility toggles exist for text blocks through the `enabled` flag, but not as a broader layer system
- [ ] Snap guides were not found
- [ ] Safe-zone editing helpers beyond stored config were not found
- [ ] Lock/unlock controls for editable elements were not found

Notes:
- This area is materially beyond MVP, and the recent Studio usability pass closed the highest-value gaps around quick/full mode, block reorder, and version compare. It still does not match the full “advanced studio” vision in the spec.

## 3. Creator presets

- [x] Creator presets table and model exist
- [x] Preset CRUD API exists
- [x] Presets can be captured from an existing card
- [x] Presets can be applied back to a card as project patches
- [x] Default preset behavior exists
- [x] Studio UI exposes preset browsing, apply, capture, and delete actions
- [x] Preset logic is covered by tests

## 4. Discovery and ranking surfaces

- [x] Public cards index includes featured, trending, latest, and rising content
- [x] Rising service exists and is tested
- [x] Related cards service exists and is tested
- [x] Remixed cards page exists
- [x] Lineage page exists
- [x] Challenge listing and challenge detail pages exist
- [x] Template packs page exists
- [x] Creator page exists
- [x] Dedicated style-family feed now exists
- [x] Dedicated palette-family feed now exists
- [x] Best-remixes discovery surface now exists
- [x] Dedicated mood feed now exists through config-backed tag mappings
- [x] Dedicated editorial landing page now exists
- [x] Dedicated seasonal landing page now exists
- [-] Discovery includes several meaningful surfaces, but not the full matrix described by the spec
- [ ] Remix-tree browsing surface beyond lineage was not found

Notes:
- Discovery is solid for core launch surfaces, but it is not yet the full “discovery intelligence” product outlined in the spec.

## 5. Creator identity and profile integration

- [x] Creator-specific public page exists for cards by user
- [x] Creator page now exposes public summary stats and creator highlight cards
- [x] Creator page now exposes featured works and featured collections
- [x] Top categories and top tags are surfaced on creator pages
- [x] Studio analytics page exists for a creator’s own card with views, likes, saves, remixes, shares, downloads, and related counters
- [x] Style family and palette family are stored on cards
- [-] Creator identity exists at the card/creator listing level, but richer creator-card identity features are not complete
- [x] Featured card rail now exists on creator pages as featured works
- [x] Featured collection rail now exists on creator pages
- [x] Dedicated Nova Cards creator portfolio page now exists
- [x] Creator pages now surface signature themes, challenge history, most remixed works, most liked works, remix branch activity, a remix graph summary, creator preference signals, and a recent creator timeline
- [-] Deeper creator identity modules are still incomplete beyond the current public portfolio summary; stronger interactive remix graphing and richer persistent preference identity are still missing
- [x] Creator spotlight eligibility/featured creators now exist for Nova Cards editorial surfacing

## 6. Social, remix, collection, challenge, and editorial support

- [x] Like, favorite, save, remix, duplicate, and challenge submission flows exist
- [x] Remix lineage is preserved and visible
- [x] Public collection detail page exists
- [x] Official collections and admin management for Nova Cards exist
- [x] Challenge admin management exists
- [x] Challenge entry visibility rules are covered by tests
- [x] Best-remixes public surface exists
- [x] Nova Cards editorial landing surfaces exist
- [x] Seasonal or themed card hubs specific to Nova Cards exist
- [x] Featured creators workflow specific to Nova Cards now exists
- [-] Editorial and community support is present, but the richer “ecosystem” layer remains incomplete

## 7. AI assistance hooks and optional UI

- [x] AI assist endpoint exists
- [x] AI assist service exists
- [x] Studio UI exposes AI suggestion requests
- [x] Suggestions include tags, mood, layout suggestions, and readability fixes
- [x] Suggestions are optional and creator-controlled
- [-] The AI assist layer appears primarily rule-based/fallback-driven rather than a deep external AI composition system
- [ ] More advanced assist actions from the spec, such as “convert to story format” or “create wallpaper version” as explicit AI actions, were not found

## 8. Export system improvements

- [x] Export request API exists
- [x] Export status polling exists
- [x] Export queue job exists
- [x] Multiple export formats exist: preview, hires, square, story, wallpaper, and OG
- [x] Export permissions are enforced via `allow_export`
- [x] Studio UI exposes export requests
- [-] Core export foundation is implemented, but richer policy/output features remain open
- [ ] Watermark policy controls were not found
- [ ] Advanced export preset management beyond format choice was not found

## 9. Trust, moderation, and rights

- [x] Card moderation status exists on the model
- [x] Reporting supports cards, comments, challenges, and challenge entries
- [x] Moderation queue/report summary integration exists
- [x] Ownership and remix-related rights flags exist, including `allow_remix`, `allow_background_reuse`, and `allow_export`
- [x] Background upload validation is enforced
- [x] API throttles and write-protection middleware are wired on key Nova Cards endpoints
- [-] Trust/moderation foundations are real, but the full anti-abuse roadmap is not complete
- [x] Publish-time duplicate-content heuristic flagging now exists for Nova Cards
- [x] Publish-time self-remix-loop heuristic flagging now exists for Nova Cards
- [x] Staff admin/reporting surfaces now expose persisted Nova Card publish heuristic reasons
- [x] Staff moderation overrides now persist actor/source metadata on Nova Cards
- [x] Staff overrides now persist moderation disposition codes like cleared/escalated/rejected
- [x] Staff moderation UI now allows selecting custom review dispositions per action
- [ ] Challenge branch freeze / remix-branch intervention tooling was not found

## 10. Backward-compatible migration strategy and rerender tooling

- [x] Migration for v3 schema additions exists
- [x] Legacy project JSON is normalized at load/use time
- [x] Older cards remain editable through normalization paths
- [x] Tests verify upgrade behavior
- [-] Compatibility is present, but operational migration tooling is incomplete
- [ ] Admin rerender tool for migrated cards was not found
- [ ] Backfill job for schema versions was not found

## 11. Acceptance criteria summary

### Studio/editor
- [x] Structured multi-block project model exists
- [x] Creator presets exist and can be reused
- [x] Versioned schema and normalization work
- [x] Exports are functional
- [x] Mobile Studio flow is usable
- [x] Studio usability pass now covers quick/full mode, text-block reorder, and version compare summaries
- [-] Full advanced editor capability set from the spec is not complete

### Social/community
- [x] Remix chains are preserved and visible
- [x] Collections are integrated into card flows
- [x] Challenge flows exist
- [-] Stronger creator identity exists only in a limited form

### Discovery
- [x] Rising and related content work
- [x] Creator, collection, challenge, and template public surfaces exist
- [-] Broader discovery matrix and editorial surfacing are incomplete

### AI assistance
- [x] Optional assistive suggestions exist
- [x] Creator remains in control
- [-] AI assistance is limited compared with the long-term vision

### Moderation/trust
- [x] Reporting and moderation hooks are in place
- [x] Attribution and basic rights controls are preserved
- [-] Anti-abuse depth from the spec is incomplete

### Technical
- [x] v1 and v2 content remain compatible through normalization
- [x] Schema migration is safe and test-covered
- [x] Render/export pipeline supports v3 features currently in use
- [-] Future-ready operational tooling is only partially present

## 12. Bottom line

- [x] Nova Cards v3 foundation is implemented
- [x] The core shipping slice is real: schema versioning, Studio improvements, presets, AI assist, exports, rising, related cards, remix lineage, challenge integration, moderation/reporting, and public browsing
- [-] Several roadmap areas are only partially implemented
- [ ] The full spec in `.vscode/agents/skinbase-nova-cards-system_v3.md` is not fully implemented end to end

## 13. Highest-value missing areas

- [ ] Advanced editor depth beyond the recent usability pass: lock/unlock, snap guides, safe-zone helpers, and broader layer controls
- [-] Rich creator identity surfaces: featured works, featured collections, and featured creators now exist, but portfolio depth and creator-history surfaces are still missing
- [x] Broader discovery surfaces now include style, palette, mood, best-remix, editorial, and seasonal pages
- [-] Stronger editorial tooling exists for cards, collections, challenges, and creators, but broader packaging and workflow depth are still limited
- [ ] Operational rerender/backfill tooling for long-term schema evolution